Musical Monday: Sweater Girl (1942)

It’s no secret that the Hollywood Comet loves musicals.
In 2010, I revealed I had seen 400 movie musicals over the course of eight years. Now that number is over 600. To celebrate and share this musical love, here is my weekly feature about musicals.

sweater girl5This week’s musical:
Sweater Girl (1942) – Musical #684

Paramount Pictures

William Clemens

Eddie Bracken, Betty Jane Rhodes, June Pressier, Phillip Terry, Nils Asther, Frieda Inescort, Kenneth Howell, Johnny Johnston (as Johnnie Johnston), William Henry, Ella Neal, Minerva Urecal, Robert Cherry, Charles D. Brown

Right before graduation, a group of college students are putting on a school musical starring Louise Menard (Rhodes) and Jack Mitchell (Bracken), who believes he has better ideas than Happy (Henry), the play’s director. During rehearsals, two of their classmates are murdered, and the students try to get to the bottom of it.

• The song “I Don’t Want to Walk Without You” was introduced in this film, which was written by Jule Styne and Frank Loesser.
• Remake of “College Scandal” (1935)
• Last film of Ella Neal
• Working titles included “Terror by Night” and “Sing a Song of Homicide.” The title was changed to “Sweater Girl” to capitalize off the sweater girl craze.

sweater girl6

June Preisser and Eddie Bracken

• The combination of a music and mystery

Notable Songs:
• “I Don’t Want to Walk Without You” performed by Johnny Johnston and later by Betty Jane Rhodes
• “Sweater Girl” performed by Eddie Bracken
• “I Said No” performed by Betty Jane Rhodes
• “What Gives Out Now?” performed by Eddie Bracken and June Preisser

sweater girl 3

My review:
This film is an unexpected delight!

“Sweater Girl” (1942) mixes a combination of elements which may seem mismatched, but blend well in this film: a college setting, a musical, comedy and murder mystery.

The film follows a group of college students who are putting on a show. But in the midst of rehearsal, some of the students are murdered. In between rehearsals, the students (primarily Eddie Bracken and June Pressier) try to investigate the murders. The show’s star Louise (Betty Jane Rhodes) is also in a secret relationship with a professor (Phillip Terry), so they are keeping it under wraps until graduation.

sweater girl

Betty Jane Rhodes in a publiciy photo for “Sweater Girl”

Musically, this film has some great songs. It’s also important in the world of music history. “Sweater Girl” introduced the song “I Don’t Want to Walk Without You,” written by Frank Loesser and Jule Styne, which became a hit during World War II. The song is first performed in the film by Johnny Johnston and then by Betty Jane Rhodes.

Though not as well known, a critic said of Betty Jane Rhodes:
“Her place in the history of popular song is secured by her having introduced on screen one of the great songs of wartime longing, “I Don’t Want to Walk Without You”

The song became best known for being performed by Harry James and his Orchestra with Helen Forrest singing.

“Sweater Girl” (1942) also provides an excellent mystery. When it’s revealed who the murderer is and why, I was so surprised I gasped. It has a great, unexpected twist!

“Sweater Girl” has the perfect combination of mystery, music and comedy, which is primarily comes from Eddie Bracken and June Pressier.

The only minor drawback is that the title may not necessarily match the film. The working title of “Sing a Song of Homicide” perhaps would have worked better, but “Sweater Girl” refers to the sweater craze of the time (made famous by Lana Turner). The film also opens with a song about sweater girls, which is to be performed in the musical show.

While I encourage everyone to find this film, I’ll share that I had to find it through different means, but if you can find it, I recommend it. It’s a good time.

Check out the Comet Over Hollywood Facebook page, follow on Twitter at @HollywoodComet or e-mail at

2 thoughts on “Musical Monday: Sweater Girl (1942)

  1. I caught “Sweater Girl” around 1960 on NYC’s Channel 2 “Early Show” and loved it. Years later, I was able to purchase a VHS tape via the internet, sold copies of it on eBay, and was amazed by the extravagant amounts of money people happily paid to buy it–and my customers all loved it. The director, William Clemens, also directed the 4 terrific Nancy Drew movies (1938-1939) starring Bonita Granville & Frankie Thomas. “Sweater Girl” features a wonderful cast of appealing young actors of 1942, three of whom (Betty Jane Rhodes, William Henry, Kenneth Howell) had the looks and talent that should have (but didn’t) guaranteed stardom!


Thank you for reading! What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.