Musical Monday: The Slipper and the Rose: The Story of Cinderella (1976)

It’s no secret that the Hollywood Comet loves musicals.
In 2010, I revealed I had seen 400 movie musicals over the course of eight years. Now that number is over 500. To celebrate and share this musical love, here is my weekly feature about musicals.

This week’s musical:
Slipper and The Rose: The Story of Cinderella (1976) – Musical #567

Paradine Co-Productions

Bryan Forbes

Richard Chamberlain, Margaret Lockwood, Kenneth More, Gemma Craven, Annette Crosbie, Edith Evans, Michael Hordern, Lally Bowers, Christopher Gable, Sherrie Hewson, Sherrie Hewson, Julian Orchard

Prince Edward (Chamberlain) of the small kingdom of Euphrania wants to marry for love. But his father the King (Hordern) needs to arrange a political marriage with a princess from another kingdom so their small domain is not invaded. Outside the palace walls, Cinderella’s (Craven) father dies and her stepmother (Lockwood) forces her into servitude. The King holds a ball so Prince Edward can find a wife and Cinderella’s fairy godmother (Crosbie) fixes it so Cinderella can go. Prince Edward and Cinderella fall in love, but their romance is complicated because she isn’t of noble blood.

-Music was written by songwriting brothers Richard and Robert Sherman, who scored several Walt Disney films.
-Margaret Lockwood’s last film
-An unknown was wanted for the role of Cinderella and the search for the role was comparable to Scarlett O’Hara. Gemma Craven was one of 150 girls interviewed for the part.
-The film was produced by journalist David Frost

Gemma Craven as Cinderella in The Slipper and the Rose

Richard Chamberlain as Prince Edward and his assistant John (Christopher Gable) in The Slipper and the Rose

Notable Songs:
-“Why Can’t I Be Two People?” performed by Richard Chamberlain
“What Has Love Got to Do with Getting Married?” performed by Michael Hordern, Lally Bowers, Edith Evans, Julian Orchard
-“Once I Was Loved” performed by Gemma Craven
-“He/She Danced With Me” performed by Richard Chamberlain, Gemma Craven

My review:
There have been many, many versions of the fairy tale “Cinderella.” There’s Walt Disney’s 1950 animated version, MGM’s Glass Slipper (1955), Rodgers and Hammerstein’s TV musicals (1957 with Julie Andrews and 1965 with Leslie Ann Warren) and even Cinderfella (1960) is Jerry Lewis — just to name a few.

This 1976 version is the same story but a little different: Rather than just following Cinderella’s story of being trapped as a servant by her step mother and sisters, but we learn more about the Prince and the kingdom’s issues as well. The Prince wants to marry for love, but the tiny kingdom needs a formal betrothal for political reasons. The kingdom needs a bride that ties them to a larger country who would aid them if they were attacked.

The story is told with 15 songs written by Richard and Robert Sherman spread throughout 2 hours and 7 minutes. And when I heard the Sherman brothers scored the film, I was excited and knew I would be hearing high-quality music.

And while the Sherman brothers are magnificent songwriters (see Mary Poppins, Summer Magic, Jungle Book, etc), the songs in “The Slipper and the Rose” are only okay. There wasn’t one song I walked away from the film humming (and can barely remember any of the tunes now as I type).

Some of the songs seemed pretty lengthy as well, especially “Position and Positioning,” “Protocoligorically Correct,” or “Tell Him Anything (But Not That I Love Him).” The 146-minute film felt very long and maybe it’s because of the sheer number of songs.

Margaret Lockwood plays the wicked step mother and the wicked step daughters are played by Sherrie Hewson and Rosalind Ayres

Aside from mediocre music and feeling like it dragged a bit, “Slipper and The Rose” has a great cast. Though Gemma Craven was fine as Cinderella, the real highlight came in the rest of the actors. Richard Chamberlain was great and has a wonderful singing voice, and it was really exciting to see Margaret Lockwood in her last film role playing the wicked stepmother. Kenneth More has a small role, as does Edith Evans and it’s wonderful to see both of those. Annette Crosbie also plays an entertaining fairy godmother, who is overworked and underpaid in magic.

Overall, “The Slipper and the Rose” is an entertaining Cinderella story that’s often overlooked. I was just disappointed in the music.

Check out the Comet Over Hollywood Facebook page, follow on Twitter at @HollywoodComet or e-mail at

7 thoughts on “Musical Monday: The Slipper and the Rose: The Story of Cinderella (1976)

  1. I hadn’t heard of this either, but I’m anxious to check it out after reading your review.


  2. I love Richard Chamberlain so I really want to like this movie, but like you I’m not super impressed with the music. It makes the movie drag along for too long.


    • I know what you mean. Richard Chamberlain was great but man I didn’t think some of the songs would ever end – Especially “Position and Positioning” and “Protocoligorically Correct.” Maybe the music wouldn’t be quite as disappointing if I hadn’t had high expectations of the songwriters.


  3. Like you I found this film disappointing. There are some good things in it, and I liked at least one of the songs, but it was overlong and most of the score needed a reboot, it just wasn’t there. A real shame given some of the talents involved. Enjoyed checking out your take!

    Best wishes,


  4. I thought the music was very good, and the scoring by Angela Morley was excellent. The score did garner an Oscar nomination but didn’t win. My favorite song was “Secret Kingdom”, although I also enjoyed “The Slipper and the Rose Waltz” (which was Oscar-nominated for Best Song”) and “Suddenly It Happens.” I agree there were some overlong productions such as “Position and Positioning,” but it’s a musical, after all, and P &P is a commentary about the restrictions of the class system, which is a major theme in this British movie.

    I first saw the film when it was first released in the US in 1977. I have to admit I did not like it at first because it seemed to be somewhat “dated”, as musicals in the mid-‘70’s were a dead genre, and the singing seemed pretty thin to someone who was too used to hearing top notch singers like Julie Andrews. However, it grew on me through subsequent viewings. I love the setting in the Austrian countryside and the costumes (especially Cinderella’s ball and wedding gowns) are to die for.

    The film was released in DVD around 1999 due to efforts of a blogger who convinced the copyright owners to restore and release the film, which had gone out of print. They did a masterful job and both the DVD and Blu-Ray are stunning.


Comments are closed.