In 2011, I announced I was trying to see every film released in 1939. This new series chronicles films released in 1939 as I watch them. As we start out this blog feature, this section may become more concrete as I search for a common thread that runs throughout each film of the year. Right now, that’s difficult.
Cast: Vera Zorina, Eddie Albert, Alan Hale, James Gleason, Queenie Smith, Frank McHugh, Leonid Kinskey, Gloria Dickson, Donald O’Connor, Erik Rhodes, Berton Churchill, William Hopper (uncredited), Carla Laemmle (uncredited),
Beginning in the 1920s, the Dancing Dolans (Gleason, Smith, O’Connor) is one of the top vaudeville performances. However, Mrs. Dolan wants her son Phil Jr. (O’Connor to Albert) to be educated and be a composer. The Dancing Dolans continue performing, but their acts are no longer well-received and vaudeville is dying. Phil Jr. meets Russian composer Ivan Boultonoff (Kinskey), and Phil composes “The Slaughter on Tenth Avenue” for the Russian Ballet. Phil reconnects with Vera (Zorina), a ballerina he knew from vaudeville, and she lobbies for the head of the ballet company (Hale) to use the music.
• This was only Eddie Albert’s second feature film; the first was Brother Rat in 1938. While not one of Warner Brother’s top leading men (like Ronald Reagan, Humphrey Bogart, Dennis Morgan or Jack Carson), Albert was a steady comedic star for Warner. Eddie Albert was a lead character in “Brother Rat,” but “On Your Toes” was his first true leading role where the plot and camera mainly followed him.
• Vera Zorina is recreating her role from the 1936 stage production of “On Your Toes”
• This was also the second American feature film for ballet dancer Vera Zorina, who appeared in a total of eight films.
• While Donald O’Connor is only a child in this film, this was his 13th film as a child star.
• James Wong Howe was the cinematographer for “On Your Toes.” Sol Polito photographed the “Slaughter on Tenth Avenue” ballet.
• Donald O’Connor plays young Eddie Albert
• Originally planned as a Fred Astaire vehicle, but Astaire turned down the film.
My review: Searching for the “1939 feature”:
So far I have watched 179 films from the year 1939. None of them have been bad, but none of them
While “On Your Toes” has three ballet numbers and some vaudeville dances at the beginning, I wouldn’t consider it a musical. There is very little singing and the focus is much more composing music and dance.
Outside of the ballet dancing, the comedy featuring Eddie Albert, James Gleason, and Alan Hale, is not very different from what you would experience in another 1930s or early-1940s Warner Brothers film.
The ballet numbers in it are gorgeously photographed by Howe and Polito. First, Vera Zorina dances beautifully in the Princess Zenobia ballet (photographed by Howe) as the audience is able to see a serious ballet performance. When Eddie Albert enters the Princess Zenobia number, the ballet scene turns away from serious dance to comedy. Albert’s character doesn’t know the dance and makes a ridicule of everyone else, but the papers think the comedy was intentional, giving the dance a good review.
“The Slaughter on Tenth Avenue” ballet is the climax of the film. This wonderful ballet scene is 13 minutes, mixing ballet and some vaudeville tap dancing.
“On Your Toes” is your standard 1930s Warner Brothers comedy. However, it’s unique in the fact that the audience is able to see a serious ballerina who danced for (and was married to) the great George Balanchine, co-founder of the New York City Ballet. Zorina was the prima ballerina in several performances for the Colonel de Basil’s Ballets Russes de Monte Carlo from 1934 to 1936.
With all the musicals I have watched, I can not recollect any other film before Michael Powell’s “The Red Shoes” (1948) that photographs a ballet performance to its full potential. For instance, in early sound films like “Broadway Melody of 1929,” you can see sloppy ballet dancing (I’m thinking specifically of the “Wedding of the Painted Doll” number).
I enjoyed “On Your Toes,” as it is a funny and entertaining film with some of Warner Brothers top comedians. It was a good mix of comedy and art with the ballet.
Check out the Comet Over Hollywood Facebook page, follow on Twitter at @HollywoodComet or e-mail at email@example.com
The credits list songs by Rodgers and Hart. I’m wondering what songs they wrote for this movie?
Rodger and Hart wrote the words and lyrics for the 1936 stage musical, however most of that did not transfer to the movie. The only song sung in this movie is “Oh, You Beautiful Doll” during a vaudeville act by the Dancing Dolans (James Gleason, Queen Smith, Donald O’Connor/Eddie Albert).
However, music written by Richard Rodgers is performed: the Princess Zenobia ballet and Slaughter on Tenth Avenue. Some of the songs from the play are apparently used as background music as well, just not performed.
This lists all the songs in the original play, but the only pieces used as they are noted here are the ballet numbers: https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-production/on-your-toes-12114/#songs
Hope that helps!
Sure does! I’m a big Rodgers and Hart fan. I have known about imdb, but ibdb is a new one on me, and I’ll find plenty of use for it. In answer to the question posed: How could Hollywood leave out the great songs? Answer: they were so busy trying to squeeze every last nickel of profit that they were willing to destroy many a movie musical.
Rodgers and Hart’s On Your Toes is one of my favorite stage musicals which I saw in London many years ago. it’s a shame Ray Bolger wasn’t allowed to repeat the role of Junior which he created on Broadway in 1936. I find it hard to watch ‘Slaughter on Tenth Avenue’ in the film because Eddie Albert is so poor. The ballerina ‘s partner should be an expert dancer.
But it’s great to see Vera Zorina recreate her Broadway success.
And how could Hollywood leave out the great songs like ‘There’s a Small Hotel’ , ‘Quiet Night’ , ‘It’s Got to be Love’ , ‘Glad to be Unhappy’ and the great title song. Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart at their peak of words and music.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s amazing you got to see this on the stage! I don’t know much about the music performed in the stage musical, but I am disappointed it wasn’t used in the film. I actually first watched this to use as a “Musical Monday,” and while I guess it still kind of is a musical…it didn’t feel right using it.
My question is how on earth do you find all the films released in 1939? Surely they’re not all available on DVD. YouTube?
Sort of like the musicals, where ever I can, honestly! Youtube, when they air on TCM, Amazon Video, etc. That’s why I’m only at 179 after starting in 2011. I’ve really just been watching them as I find them, rather than actively seeking out.
LikeLiked by 1 person